[A2k] FT: The endgame for EU copyright laws

Thiru Balasubramaniam thiru at keionline.org
Tue Sep 11 04:45:52 PDT 2018


Brussels Briefing European Union

The endgame for EU copyright laws

Wyclef Jean will push MEPs to vote against the ‘death of the internet’ and
the ‘end of memes’

Mehreen Khan in Strasbourg

Ready or not, here he comes. Wyclef Jean is in the European Parliament in
Strasbourg on Tuesday.

It’s another slice of novelty news spawned by a battle about EU rules
affecting internet companies and creatives that, for the last two years,
has sucked in celebrities and helped feed the Brussels lobbyist machine.

Wyclef will be pushing MEPs to vote on Wednesday against draft EU copyright
laws that have been called the “death of the internet” and the “end of
memes”. It's long running tussle that should come to a denouement this week.

The campaigns for and against the copyright changes have involved
ex-Beatles, Wikipedia’s Jimmy Wales, Stephen Fry, award-winning war
journalists, US tech giants, and now, the former Fugee.

At stake is the first update of European copyright rules for over 15 years.
Back then, musicians, artists, and authors were not considered “content
creators” and didn't need search engines or streaming sites to make a
living. The European Commission’s idea to update copyright rules was meant
to create a fair way for rights holders to get paid for their work in the
digital age.

Wyclef is in Strasbourg arguing against one of the most controversial parts
of the plans, which would require platforms to pre-scan user generated
content to make sure it doesn’t break copyright rules (“upload filters”).
Unlike many in the music industry — including Sir Paul McCartney — Wyclef
thinks it will hurt rather than protect artists. Others say it will outlaw

Another sore point is a so called “link tax” that would force Google and
others to pay news websites for hosting hyperlinks to their stuff. Media
giants like Agence France-Presse — backed by the French state — are
supporters arguing the revenues can help sustain quality journalism (here’s
an easy to read version of the whole text).

Earlier this summer, MEPs decided they needed more time to think after
opposition reached nearly 1m signatures in an online petition.
Parliamentarians have spent the last three months fighting about
alternative versions of the two most toxic ideas to seal a deal this week.
But they seem as far apart as ever.

More than 200 possible amendments have been tabled, with the main ones due
to come to a vote on Wednesday. The EU’s big political groups are split.
There’s still an outside chance the vote might not happen at all if the
parliament’s president decides the whole thing is just too messy.

The commission has told the FT that no deal is not better than a bad deal.
It wants parliament to find a compromise on Wednesday or risk the whole
initiative being shelved until a new crop of MEPs are elected in May.

Whatever the outcome, one way or another, plenty will be relieved to see
the back of this debate once and for all.

Thiru Balasubramaniam
Geneva Representative
Knowledge Ecology International
41 22 791 6727
thiru at keionline.org

More information about the A2k mailing list