[Ip-health] Bayer's correspond with Nina Mahmud, rejecting request for affordable Nexavar for Fathi Helmi Aboseda, in Egypt
james.love at keionline.org
Tue Sep 23 05:18:51 PDT 2014
Note, this blog included a copy of Bayer's April 5, 2014 response to Nina
Mahmud, rejecting her request for affordable Nexavar for Fathi Helmi
Aboseda, a letter we are publishing for the first time. Jamie
Source URL: http://keionline.org/node/2089
Bayer's correspond with Nina Mahmud, rejecting request for affordable
Nexavar for Fathi Helmi Aboseda, in Egypt
23. September 2014
Today we received news from Nina Mahmud that her father-in-law, Fathi Helmi
Aboseda, has passed away in Egypt. Mr. Aboseda was suffering from liver
cancer. Earlier this year, Nina Mahmud had contacted Bayer and KEI asking
for help in finding affordable copies of sorafenib, a drug for liver and
kidney cancer sold by Bayer under the trade name Nexavar, a drug that was
extending and improving the quality of his life. The price of Nexavar in
Egypt was $900 per week, and Mr. Aboseda had used his entire life savings
to buy the drug.
In an April 5, 2014 letter, which we are publishing here [see below], for
the first time, Bayer rejected her plea.
After Bayer rejected the request for a discount on the price of Nexavar in
India, several persons, including three persons in India and two people in
Egypt, found a way to bring a few months of generic copies of sorafenib to
Nina's family in Egypt. This turned out to be quite difficult.
* The India compulsory license for the patents on sorafenib did not permit
sales outside of the territory of Egypt, following pressure from the United
States, including personal interventions from President Obama, Vice
President Biden, two secretaries of Commerce, the head of the USPTO, the US
Department of State under Hillary Clinton and John Kerry, and Michael
Froman, now head of the USTR.
DHL refused to ship the generic versions of the drug from India to Egypt,
without an original copy of a prescription from an Indian doctor and a
certificate of drug registration from the Egyptian drug regulators.
* Egypt wanted the drug registered in Egypt before issuing a compulsory
license on the patents in Egypt.
* It was difficult to get timely visas for people from India or Egypt to
make a plane trip to deliver the drug.
* All of these barriers were overcome, but it was quite difficult , and not
something that can scale. These cases remind us why intellectual property
and trade policy are important.
Below are the correspondence between Nina Mahmud and Bayer, as well as some
video interviews we did with Nina during her February 2014 trip to
Our thoughts are with the Aboseda family, knowing this is a great loss for
Bayer's April 5, 2014 response to Nina Mahmud, rejecting request for
affordable Nexavar for Fathi Helmi Aboseda, in Egypt.
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Joseph Philip Hendrik Smits
Date: Sat, Apr 5, 2014 at 12:47 AM
To: "nina.a.mahmud at gmail.com"
Ms. Nina Mahmud
Dear Ms. Mahmud,
The president of Bayer Corporation in the U.S., Philip Blake, reached out
to me regarding your February 14, 2014, correspondence and asked me to
reply to you on his behalf.
We have great sympathy for what you and your family are experiencing.
We have consulted with our colleagues in Egypt and learned that our
company's endeavors to put in place a Patient Access Program in cooperation
with the Egyptian authorities are still underway, and we will continue to
work closely to establish a program for Nexavar in Egypt. We are optimistic
that the necessary measures to provide all patients with the medications
they require will be implemented soon.
Please understand that as an ethical company we cannot interact directly to
provide patients with pharmaceutical products.
In your letter, you also reference the topic of innovation which is closely
linked to the topic of Intellectual Property. As Intellectual Property is
the lifeblood of the biopharmaceutical industry, please allow me to explain
We realize and accept the responsibility we have to make our medicines
accessible and affordable to the widest number of patients possible.
Furthermore, we are committed to finding sustainable and effective ways to
improve access to our medicines. In fact, we work with aid organizations
and governments on different health-related programs.
But we can only continue to do so and to develop innovative medicines for
the unmet medical needs of patients if our business model stays intact. And
a key element of this model is the intellectual property right linked to
such an innovative medicine which we therefore can't compromise.
With kind regards, Philip Smits, MD, General Manager Bayer Healthcare
---------- Forwarded message ----------
Nina Mahmud's February 14, 2014 letter to Philip Blake, President of Bayer
Corporation in the U.S.
February 14, 2014
Dear Mr. Philip Blake,
My name is Nina Mahmud and my father in law is Fathi Helmi Aboseda. He is
dying from Liver Cancer and needs Nexavar. He lives in Alexandria, Egypt
where Nexavar is sold for $1,724 US dollars for 2 weeks supply of
medication. The cost of Nexavar has already depleted the family’s life
savings and cannot afford his next bottle of Nexavar. Currently, he only
has enough Nexavar
to last him through this Saturday, February 15th, 2014.
He and his twin brother own a market and he earns approximately $280 a
month. To afford the next bottle of Nexavar we have to sell the family
business which may take a few months and will only provide 9 months of
Nexavar. This is the family business that would have been passed down to
the next generation for their future means of income. After that we will
have nothing left to sell.
Fathi started Nexavar on December 4, 2013 and as of last week his lab
values have returned to normal range and his tumors have shrunk. However,
he will not survive long off of Nexavar. Fathi is the father of Mohamed (my
husband), Maged, Mai and Maha and the grandfather of 3 beautiful children,
Omar (4 years old), Eiad (2 years old) and Amir (1 year old). He also
helped raise his 5 nephews and nieces when their mother died at a young
age. He is married to Nadia, the love ofhis life, for 39 years.
I am asking Bayer to immediately sell Nexavar in Egypt at a price that
people can afford. It is not realistic to provide a 1 month supply of
Nexavar at $3732 US dollars in a country where the average earning is less
than a $100 US dollars a month.
If there's truth to Bayer Pharmaceuticals mission and value statement then
they need to immediately make Nexavar affordable to everyone.
If Bayer is a ‘science for a better life’ then allow the opportunity for a
better life to everyone regardless of socioeconomic status or country of
If Bayer is a ‘worldclass innovation company’ then let that innovation be
accessible to people in both the developing and industrial countries.
If Bayer’s ‘scientific achievements aim to help improve people’s lives by
addressing the great challenges of our time’ then help improve the great
challenges in everyone’s lives.
If Bayer’s aim is to ‘discover and manufacture products that will improve
human health worldwide by diagnosing, preventing and treating diseases’
then do so and make Nexavar accessible and affordable to everyone.
Steps that Bayer can take to make Nexavar accessible and affordable to
everyone include: (1) selling Nexavar at prices that are affordable, in
each county where the drug is sold, and/or, (2) for countries where Bayer
is clearly not serving everyone in a country, license the relevant patents
to generic drug companies, so they can make and sell generic versions at a
price point that better reflects peoples’ incomes, in that country.
Bayer is very wrong to block every effort to expand access to affordable
supplies of Nexavar, and to price Nexavar only “ for Western patients who
can afford this product." Please do not let my children lose the
opportunity of having their grandfather in their lives simply because
Nexavar is too expensive for us to afford.
I would like to schedule a meeting with you and your staff to follow up on
the concrete steps that Bayer can take to address the the pricing policies
that currently strip people of all of their assets, their life’s work, and
their ability to provide for their spouses, children and other dependents,
and which even make access impossible, and which have terrible negative
impact on their health and life expectancy.
nina.a.mahmud at gmail.com
Playlist of interviews with Nina Mahmud, during her February 2014 visit to
Washington, DC, to confront Bayer at an ITC hearing on India.
September 22, 2014 message from Nina Mahmud, regarding the death of Fathi
From: Nina Mahmud
September 22, 2014.
to: Claire, Manon, Jamie, ip-health
Hello Mr. Love,
I want to let you know that my father-in-law passed away last Friday
approximately 4pm Eastern time. He finished the medication a few weeks ago
and soon after everything started to fail. He was admitted to the ICU last
week and hospice last Thursday. Everything happened very quick. You know
it's inevitable but you can never be fully prepared.
I have spent the last few months trying to figure out how I can thank you
and everyone who played a role in helping my father-in-law access
medication. You gave us time and that's been priceless for the whole
family. I don't know how to repay that, but know you, Manon, Claire and
everyone are in my thoughts and prayers every night (except Bayer of
course. I give them the evil eye daily). Everyone is still in shock and
grieving. I hope to talk to you soon. I am currently without a cell phone
but will call you when I get one.
I know my father-in-law is watching over us all from Heaven including the
Have a beautiful week and be blessed,
Sent with Love
Source URL: http://keionline.org/node/2089
James Love. Knowledge Ecology International
KEI DC tel: +1.202.332.2670, US Mobile: +1.202.361.3040, Geneva Mobile:
More information about the Ip-health