[Ip-health] Appeal from Asian Civil Society to discuss the report of United Nations Secretary-General’s High-Level Panel on Access to Medicines (HLP) at the forthcoming WHO Executive Board

leena menghaney leenamenghaney at gmail.com
Fri Nov 18 03:06:25 PST 2016

Dr. Margaret Chan, Director-General, World Health Organization, Switzerland

Dr Poonam Khetrapal Singh, Regional Director of WHO South-East Asia Region,
New Delhi

Dr. Raymond Busuttil, Chairman of the Executive Board, World Health

18 November 2016

*Re: Appeal from Asian Civil Society to the DG to discuss the report of
United Nations Secretary-General’s High-Level Panel on Access to Medicines
(HLP) at the forthcoming EB*

Dear Dr. Margaret Chan, Dr. Singh and Dr. Busuttil,

We write to you as health organisations, patient networks, treatment
providers and rights activists from the Asian region to highlight our
concern regarding the failure of your office and five officers of the World
Health Organization’s (WHO) Executive Board to place the Report of the UN
Secretary-General’s High-Level Panel on Access to Medicines” (UN HLP) on
the agenda of the 140th session of the WHO Executive Board in January 2017.

Against a back drop of spiraling drug, diagnostics and vaccine prices and
innovation failures, the High-Level Panel was constituted to advise the UN
Secretary-General, Member States and other relevant stakeholders on
concrete recommendations to improving innovation and access to health
technologies, building on the work done by WHO and “remedying the policy
incoherence between the justifiable rights of inventors, international
human rights law, trade rules and public health in the context of health

The final report released this September clearly recognizes that today all
countries – developed and developing - face challenges in ensuring
availability and affordable access and innovation to the pharmaceutical
products that people need to live healthy lives.

The report calls for negotiation of a binding international treaty on R&D,
delinking prices from R&D costs, greater transparency in drug pricing,
public health impact assessments as an imperative to inform trade
agreements negotiations, and encouragement to countries to better use
international legal tools available under WTO rules to ensure affordable
medical products.

Delays by WHO to place the UN HLP report and recommendations on the agenda
of the WHO’s EB and subsequently at the World Health Assembly - to
encourage member countries to debate, discuss and take forwards the
implementation of this critically important report - are unacceptable.

In this context we could like to draw your attention to the 12 September
2016 request by eleven WHO member states of the South East Asia Region (and
supported by Brazil, Islamic Republic of Iran and Republic of South Africa)
to place an item entitled “Report of the UN Secretary-General’s High-Level
Panel on Access to Medicines” (UN HLP) on the agenda of the 140th session
of the WHO Executive Board in January 2017.

According to the Note for the Record of the “Teleconference with the
Officers of the Executive Board regarding the draft provisional agenda of
the 140th session (January 2017)”, on 28 September 2016, you and five
Officers of the Executive Board arbitrarily rejected a request by those
fourteen countries to hold a discussion of the Final Report of the UN HLP
at the January 2017 meeting.

We find this rejection to be arbitrary and unacceptable and calls into
question your commitment to WHO’s Global Strategy and Plan of Action on
Public Health, Innovation and Intellectual Property, the Follow-up of the
report of the Consultative Expert Working Group on Research and
Development: Financing and Coordination, the Sustainable Development Goals
(SDGs) and the realization of the right to health.

We call on you to provide leadership to take forward the United Nations
Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon’s initiative. As the UN’s specialized agency
tasked with protecting public health, WHO should lead from the front.

We ask you to reconsider your action on this matter, and respect Member
States’ wishes to convene a discussion on the recommendations of the
High-Level Panel In January 2017.


AIDS Access Foundation, Thailand

All India Drug Action Network (AIDAN)

Asian Network of People who Use Drugs (ANPUD)

Anandi Yuvaraj, Independent Consultant HIV, Sexual Health Rights, India

Ashok Row Kavi, LGBT rights activist

Astitva Trust - Organization for Support & Development of Sexual
Minorities, India

Advocacy Rights of Transgender & Hijra (ARTH), India

Andhra Pradesh Positive Women's Network (APWN+), India

Campaign for Affordable Trastuzumab, India

Coalition of Drug Users in Nepal (CDUN)

Delhi Network of Positive People  (DNP+), India

Drug Study Group, Thailand

Dr. Mira Shiva, India

Dr. Smarajit Jana, India

Delhi Positive Women's Network, DPWN+, India

Foundation for AIDS Rights (FAR), Thailand

Foundation for Consumers, Thailand

Friends of Kidney Failure Patients Group, Thailand

FTA Watch, Thailand

Freedom Foundation-India (Centres of Excellence- Substance Abuse &
HIV/AIDS), India

Gujarat State Network of People living with HIV/AIDS (GSNP+)

Haryana Positive Women's Network (HPWN+), India

Initiative for Health & Equity in Society, India

Indonesia AIDS Coalition (IAC)

Kerala Positive Women's Network (KPWN+), India

Khmer HIV/AIDS NGO Alliance (KHANA), Combodia

Karnataka Positive Women's Network (KPWN+ ), India

Laxmi Narayan Tripathi, Transgender Rights Activist, India

Leena Menghaney, Lawyer and patient living with Asthma

Maharashtra Thritya Panthi Sangatana, India

Mona Mishra, International Development consultant, India

Manipur All Positive Women's Network, MAPWN+, India

Mizoram Positive Women's Network (MPWN+), India

Maharashtra Positive Women's Network (MPWN+), India

Network of PLHIV living in the Asia Pacific region (APN+)

Network of Maharashtra People with HIV (NMP+), India

National Coalition of People living with HIV in India (NCPI+), India

Nai Umang+, Positive Welfare Society, New Delhi, India

Nagaland Positive Women's Network (NPWN+), India

Positive Malaysian Treatment Access & Advocacy Group (MTAAG+)

Positive Women Network (PWN+), India

Pondicherry Positive Women's Network (PPWN+), India

Orissa Positive Women's Network (OPWN+), India

Rural Pharmacists Group, Thailand

*Sanghamitra Iyengar, Mental Health Professional*

Sindi Putri, HIV Activist, Indonesia

Stop Drink Network, Thailand

Sankalp Rehabilitation Trust, India

Samraksha, Karnataka, India

Saksham Positive Women's Network, India

Thai AIDS Treatment Action Group (TTAG), Thailand

Thai Holistic Health Foundation, Thailand

Thai NGO Coalition on AIDS, Thailand

Thai Network of People Living with HIV/AIDS (TNP+), Thailand

Tamil Nadu Positive Women's Network (TPWN+, India

Uttar Pradesh Positive Women's Network (UPWN+), India

Vietnam Network of People living with HIV (VNP+), Vietnam

More information about the Ip-health mailing list