[Ip-health] The Brussels Times: Belgium’s plea for sick toddler denied by pharmaceutical giant Novartis

Thiru Balasubramaniam thiru at keionline.org
Mon Sep 23 22:13:33 PDT 2019


Belgium’s plea for sick toddler denied by pharmaceutical giant Novartis

Friday, 20 September 2019
A government request to make the world's most expensive drug available to a
Belgian toddler has been denied by pharmaceutical giant Novartis. Credit: ©

A remarkable crowdfunding effort for a Belgian toddler suffering from a
life-threatening genetic disease has seen one of the world’s largest
pharmaceutical firms shut down government appeals to their “humanity.”

Pharmaceutical giant Novartis denied a request from the federal government
to make the most expensive medicine in the world available for free to Pia,
a Belgian toddler who suffers from spinal muscular atrophy and has made the
headlines in recent days following a notable crowdfunding success by her

By launching a nation-wide SMS campaign, the toddler’s family managed to
pool together the €1.9 million needed to afford the gene therapy Zolgensma,
a drug which has yet to receive approval for the European market.

On Thursday, Federal Health Minister Maggie De Block urged the company to
“remain human” and give the medicine to 9-month-old Pia, but the minister’s
cabinet said the company had refused their request, a refusal which they
see as unjustified.

Zolgensma is the most expensive drug in the world and was hailed as a
breakthrough in the treatment of the aggressive disease which progressively
leads to muscular failure and sees most children diagnosed with it die in
early infancy.

Company must ‘remain human’

With the therapy yet to receive approval to enter the European market, De
Block on Thursday said the “largely public-funded” company should make it
available under a program known as compassionate use (CUP).

“A company that markets a drug whose development is largely funded by
public money and by patient organisations has a social responsibility and
must remain human,” De Block said in an address to parliament, according to
Het Nieuwsblad.

CUP allows national governments to request pharmaceutical firms to provide
drugs to a patient for free pending their market approval.

A spokesperson for De Block said that, despite the fact that they
considered the conditions for CUP were met in the case of Pia, their
request to Novartis had been rejected.

“We addressed a CUP request to the firm, but they refused,” Audrey Dorigo,
a spokesperson for De Block, told The Brussels Times.

No compassionate use

“We find that their refusal is not justified,” Dorigo added, citing cases
where other pharmaceutical firms had agreed to provide a non-approved drug
under the CUP.

A media relations officer for Novartis did not reply to multiple requests
for comment but provided a statement released ahead of De Blocks’
statements on Thursday.

“We are in constant dialogue (…) with government bodies to find solutions
for early access for all our innovative treatments for patients who can
benefit from them,” the statement read, adding that the company could not
comment on individual patient cases like Pia’s.

“We considered it the duty of the firm to make the medicine available,”
Dorigo said, adding that a long-term solution needed to be found for
patients in cases similar to Pia’s.

The toddler’s family told Het Nieuwsblad that the firm’s refusal to a
request they had made several times was “not news” to them.

“What is news is the public pressure,” they said, adding that they would be
looking to speak with Novartis “as soon as possible.”

Gabriela Galindo
The Brussels Times

Thiru Balasubramaniam
Geneva Representative
Knowledge Ecology International
41 22 791 6727
thiru at keionline.org

More information about the Ip-health mailing list